+- Blitzortung.org Forum (https://forum.blitzortung.org/mybb)
+-- Forum: Public Forums (https://forum.blitzortung.org/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=29)
+--- Forum: General Discussion (https://forum.blitzortung.org/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=31)
+--- Thread: When are kits back in stock? (/showthread.php?tid=707)
RE: When are kits back in stock? - RichoAnd - 2014-09-09
I'm testing some future improvements but is interrupted daily by friendly people who "just" want my private service.
I always answer, and also correspond as best I can in the forum.
It's cozy, but it's time from the development.
My part of the development is driven by opportunities in software development.
Software developers get even more emails and becomes more upset than I am.
They can choose to ignore or respond - if they answer it goes beyond development.
If no reply, they are ignorant.
The easy stuff is done between the answers - the tough gets postponed.
What would take weeks, taking instead months.
Whatever the intention was, given the balance all the time.
There are challenges in the development just to be done - it just can not be outsourced, as it also takes a long time to describe the challenges and changed along the way.
There is no recipe that tells how to make a fast growing network of advanced receivers.
Much to be tested before we can say that now everything is as it should be, and we have no need to make changes soon.
Developments from GREEN to RED due Tobis restless nights and subsequent testing of the Discovery module. - It opened a lot of options, and each option gave even more options. - At one point was drawn a line, and System RED was born.
It was only a short satisfaction using a development kit as engine in the Controller
Right now people are shouting at more of the same kind, but would it be better to have our own board?
Can it be made better and cheaper?
IF - should it be made with SMD components?
IF - should it be made in the Far East?
IF - should there be more channels or fewer channels?
IF - should it stand alone or be combined with the receiver?
IF - should amplifiers changed.
IF - should the filters change?
IF - will they be compatible with earlier system.
There are hundreds of other questions and thoughts
Some are exchanged, some matures.
Should we use the new ideas until we have resolved all previous challenges.?
To produce thousands of System RED, we must be 100% confident that we have made the final product. - We were not with GREEN and we are not with RED.
Status: I'm testing future circuits.
What Egon and Tobias are doing? - I do not know, but I suppose they work, rejects the family, and spend all their free time to improve our system.
The order of their work depends on how much they are disturbed.
You guys know it - late in the evening before going to sleep in, sit straight and make a solitaire - we do not, we sit and solve minor problems, and think about when we will have time solving the big challenges.
I can only speak for myself. I could not think of disturbing Egon and Tobias unnecessarily
/richo
RE: When are kits back in stock? - flc85 - 2014-09-09
Quote: I have a life, and work, and other projects, just like everyone else.
Developers also I think
RE: When are kits back in stock? - Tobi - 2014-09-09
Hi,
currently it would be nonsense to sell more and more stations while the TOA system itself is not capable to handle it. It's not a matter of system power (we have enough), but a matter of the algorithms which have to be improved. This takes a lot of time and a lot of research. It's an ongoing process since the project has started years ago and it has got more important due to the fast growing since last year. Please also remember the we introduced the new RED system just a year ago. This year was the first possibility to test this new system under real heavy conditions. It's working well, but there's still a lot of potential in combination with the TOA algorithms.
Also note, that we never shipped so much stations like this year. Lot of them are still not assembled and from our experience several will not be assembled at all. During the last weeks we shipped mainly to regions with (almost) no coverage. It's almost sure that we won't send much more stations until end of the year or next year.
Regards
Tobias
RE: When are kits back in stock? - Andrew.Instone-Cowie - 2014-09-09
Thank you for the feedback, Tobias.
I don't see a problem with buying in parts of the solution ready made (like the Discovery board for example) if that frees up time to work on development of the things that are perhaps more important (like amplifiers and algorithms, and the back-end systems without which we are just some boxes of flashing lights). Unless of course the Discovery is causing you some particular headaches, why re-invent that wheel?
I would not like to see the stations become only available pre-assembled. I can buy any amount of ready-made "toys" that just plug in; Building the station was part of the challenge
Andrew
RE: When are kits back in stock? - tpweather - 2014-09-11
When and how will we know when kits are available?
RE: When are kits back in stock? - Kimito weatherstation - 2014-09-11
(2014-09-11, 12:10)tpweather Wrote: When and how will we know when kits are available?You have to wait
RE: When are kits back in stock? - Detlef_A - 2014-09-11
This kind of communication scheme is intransparent, the conduct of the people in charge is arrogant: "keep them stupid, the idiots"
There are other projects, who can keep there clientele much more happy. Maybe you still can improve, hopefully.
Cheers
Detlef
DD4WV
RE: When are kits back in stock? - BobW - 2014-09-11
(2014-09-11, 18:59)Detlef_A Wrote: This kind of communication scheme is intransparent, the conduct of the people in charge is arrogant: "keep them stupid, the idiots"
There are other projects, who can keep there clientele much more happy. Maybe you still can improve, hopefully.
Cheers
Detlef
DD4WV
I have no connection to the project management, so I am an outsider. Let's address what you are trying to say....
"Maybe you still can improve, hopefully"
They are. They are spending time on the Infrastructure, instead of putting together kits of parts containing a billion little pieces each, some of which are never built.
"This kind of communication scheme is intransparent, the conduct of the people in charge is arrogant: "keep them stupid, the idiots""
Did anyone other than you actually say that? That I think, is your interpretation.
"There are other projects, who can keep there clientele much more happy."
What's to be unhappy about? Everyone has access to the product - lightning locations. Having a receiving station doesn't actually help the station owner locate lightning. The station owner helps others by having it. Just as those others help the station owner.
There is nothing to keep you from building the station without getting a kit of parts. The schematic for the controller and amps is shown, and it can be built. The Discovery firmware and the firmware for the amp controllers can be downloaded.
Look at the pictures of what the kit contains. Making the kits of parts - and procuring, and getting all the parts into the kit - is alot of work.
Also - your profile doesn't say where you live - the current batch of kits were likely provided to areas that were lacking coverage. You may be in a well covered area, so you may be further down the list of priorities. In my case, the closest station from me was 400 miles in any direction. The network needed coverage where I am.
They are managing the network in the best way they can.
RE: When are kits back in stock? - weatherc - 2014-09-11
No, i'm not waiting for a kit as i have one.
But, as following the discussion about new kits i have to agree with the disappointed peeps in this thread.
The communication could have much much better, actually the communication-strategy seen last weeks/monts has been exactly the opposite vs what it should have been.
- There are a huge demand for new kits who's looks and looks for when they will be available, OK.
- First, in beginning of July, they are out for month-two. OK. But nowhere was any closer status about this.
- When the kits finally went available, was there, if i remember right, nowhere any statements about the limited amount and that they are available only for areas with bad coverage.
- And then few days later they went out for the rest of the year.
- As the creame of the cake was there some kind of "automatic answering-mashine-moderator" who put virtually same answer on all the questions.
With this strategy, and if had waited for a kit, i had been really disappointed too, and, looked for other solutions.
Its of course easy to say afterwards but
1. Why was the network expanded outside Europe if it is not ready for it?
2. Why not expand to just one area at time instead of whole world at once?
// Henkka
RE: When are kits back in stock? - Jonathan.Williams - 2014-09-11
Folks, please remember that this project has literally exploded over the last four months, after existing for several years. The volunteer developers (all three of them!), within the last year and a half, produced a brand new, upgraded station type, as well.
There are going to be some hiccups as the project expands, and as the capabilities of the new hardware are worked in to the system. And yes, from what I've seen, that includes revamping the way project kits are sent. But these things cannot be done overnight--especially when project expansion is NOT just about sending more kits.
I know "please be patient" doesn't get you a kit any faster, but I do hope people can understand. This is a volunteer effort from top to bottom, the developers have actual day jobs as well, and the parameters have changed significantly in the last half year.
Of course, if you're itching to solder something, work on another project for now! No one says that's a bad thing. The Blitzortung project is not ending.
Anyone want to guesstimate how much data (bits/second) flow into the BO servers? If you think about it, it's not that hard to understand why a system that was adequate for fewer stations, expanding at a certain rate, is now in need of revamping and improvement.